DREIESKIVA​|Roald Kvam

Voltaire, one of the most influential thinkers of the Enlightenment, was a fierce critic of religious dogma, superstition, and irrational belief systems. In Miracles and Idolatry, he examines the concepts of miracles and idolatry, challenging their validity and questioning their impact on society. He argues that belief in miracles is often rooted in ignorance, manipulated by religious authorities to control the masses, and fundamentally opposed to reason and empirical evidence. Likewise, he critiques idolatry as a product of human tendency toward superstition, often used to justify oppressive religious and political structures. Through his sharp wit and philosophical reasoning, Voltaire dismantles these notions, advocating instead for reason, skepticism, and the pursuit of true knowledge.

Let’s explore…

The nature of miracles and the problem of credibility

Voltaire begins by defining miracles as events that supposedly defy the natural order of things and cannot be explained by reason or scientific principles. He immediately questions their credibility, arguing that human history is replete with fraudulent or exaggerated miracle claims. He highlights how different religions have attributed miraculous occurrences to their gods, prophets, or saints, yet these claims often contradict one another. If all religious groups claim divine intervention, but their beliefs are mutually exclusive, how can they all be true?

He further asserts that miracle claims are frequently made by religious institutions seeking to consolidate power. By convincing people that miracles are real, these institutions can demand obedience, foster unquestioning faith, and suppress dissent. Voltaire points out that many so-called miracles rely on secondhand testimony, hearsay, or religious texts written centuries after the supposed events. Such weak evidence, he argues, should not be accepted by any rational mind.

Faith vs. reason: The enlightenment perspective

A core argument in Miracles and Idolatry is that belief in miracles contradicts the Enlightenment values of reason and empirical inquiry. Voltaire maintains that a rational world operates according to fixed natural laws. If miracles were real, they would imply that these laws can be arbitrarily broken, leading to an inconsistent and chaotic universe. Science, he argues, has consistently demonstrated that natural laws govern reality, and any claim of supernatural intervention should be met with skepticism unless irrefutable proof is provided.

Voltaire also criticizes the tendency of religious believers to accept miracle stories without question. He argues that people often believe in miracles not because of evidence but because they have been conditioned to accept religious teachings from a young age. Faith, in this sense, is not a path to truth but a mechanism for social control. He calls for a shift away from blind faith and toward a culture of critical thinking and scientific exploration.

Idolatry: A reflection of human superstition

In the second part of his discussion, Voltaire turns his attention to idolatry. He defines idolatry as the worship of physical objects, images, or symbols believed to possess divine power. He traces its origins to early human societies, where people, unable to comprehend natural phenomena, attributed supernatural significance to objects like statues, animals, and celestial bodies.

Voltaire argues that idolatry is a natural but misguided response to fear and ignorance. When people do not understand the causes of events—whether storms, plagues, or victories in battle—they often resort to supernatural explanations. Over time, these beliefs become institutionalized, leading to elaborate religious traditions that venerate specific idols. However, these traditions are often arbitrary and vary widely between cultures, further proving their human rather than divine origins.

The hypocrisy of organized religion

One of Voltaire’s sharpest critiques is directed at organized religion’s hypocrisy regarding idolatry. He notes that while many religious traditions condemn idolatry, they often practice their own forms of it. For example, the Catholic Church denounces idol worship but venerates relics, saints, and sacred objects in ways that closely resemble the very practices they criticize in other religions.

Voltaire also examines how religious authorities use idolatry to manipulate believers. By controlling sacred images, relics, and symbols, religious institutions can reinforce their power and maintain influence over the faithful. He criticizes how religious leaders claim divine authority and exploit people’s fears to gain wealth and political dominance.

The danger of superstition and religious intolerance

For Voltaire, belief in miracles and idolatry are not just intellectual errors but sources of real harm. He argues that superstition fosters ignorance and prevents societies from progressing. When people attribute events to supernatural causes, they are less likely to seek rational explanations or scientific solutions. This hinders medical advancements, technological progress, and overall intellectual development.

Additionally, Voltaire warns that superstition often leads to religious intolerance. When people believe their miracles and idols are the only true ones, they become hostile toward those who think differently. This has historically led to persecution, violence, and war. He cites examples of religious conflicts, including the Crusades and the Inquisition, to illustrate the dangers of fanaticism. He argues that a society based on reason, rather than superstition, would be more just, peaceful, and free.

Voltaire’s call for rational inquiry

Ultimately, Voltaire’s message in Miracles and Idolatry is a call for rational inquiry and skepticism. He urges people to question religious authorities, examine evidence critically, and embrace scientific reasoning. He does not outright reject spirituality or the possibility of a higher power, but he insists that beliefs should be grounded in reason rather than blind faith.

Voltaire envisions an enlightened society where individuals think for themselves and are not shackled by dogma. He advocates for a secular approach to governance and education, where religious beliefs are a personal matter rather than a state-imposed doctrine. He sees intellectual freedom as essential for human progress and argues that a world governed by reason would be far more just and prosperous.

---

In Miracles and Idolatry, Voltaire masterfully critiques the irrational aspects of religious belief, exposing how faith in miracles and idol worship stems from ignorance and manipulation. He challenges his readers to move beyond superstition and embrace reason as the true path to knowledge and progress. His arguments remain relevant today, as societies continue to grapple with the tension between faith and reason. Through his incisive wit and philosophical depth, Voltaire remains a champion of the Enlightenment ideals that continue to shape modern thought.