DREIESKIVA​|Roald Kvam

Charles Darwin’s On Natural Selection is one of the most influential scientific works in history. Originally part of his seminal book On the Origin of Species (1859), this section explains the fundamental mechanism that drives the evolution of species. Darwin presents natural selection as the primary force shaping the diversity of life, arguing that organisms best suited to their environment survive and reproduce, while those less adapted perish. This process, he suggests, leads to the gradual evolution of species over time. Below is a detailed summary of his key arguments and ideas.

Let’s explore…

Introduction to natural selection

Darwin begins by addressing the power of variation within species, noting that individuals of the same species are not identical. He draws comparisons between artificial selection, as practiced by breeders, and natural selection, suggesting that nature itself acts as a selective force. Through selective breeding, humans have been able to produce dramatic variations in domesticated animals and plants, such as different breeds of pigeons and varieties of crops. If artificial selection can cause such significant changes in just a few generations, Darwin argues, then nature, working over vast time periods, could bring about even more profound transformations.

The struggle for existence

One of Darwin’s most important concepts is the “struggle for existence.” He borrows this idea from the economist Thomas Malthus, who wrote that human populations grow faster than food supplies, leading to competition for resources. Darwin extends this principle to all living organisms, emphasizing that because more individuals are born than can possibly survive, there is an inevitable struggle for survival. This struggle is not always direct conflict but can include competition for food, avoidance of predators, or adaptation to environmental changes. Those individuals with traits that offer even the slightest advantage are more likely to survive and pass on their genes to the next generation.

Variation and heritability

For natural selection to work, there must be variation among individuals within a species. Darwin observes that such variations exist in nature, though he admits that he does not fully understand the mechanisms behind inheritance (a mystery that would later be explained by genetics). Some variations are beneficial, some are neutral, and some are detrimental. Over generations, beneficial traits accumulate because they enhance an organism’s ability to survive and reproduce, while harmful traits tend to disappear.

The principle of divergence and speciation

Darwin explains that over time, the accumulation of small changes can lead to significant differences between populations, eventually resulting in the emergence of new species. This principle, known as divergence, helps to explain the great variety of life on Earth. As populations adapt to different environments, they become increasingly distinct from one another. This process of speciation can occur gradually, with small adaptations accumulating over long periods.

Darwin also suggests that closely related species often share a common ancestor, which implies that all life on Earth is connected through a vast evolutionary tree. He challenges the prevailing belief in the immutability of species, arguing that all organisms are in a constant state of change, shaped by environmental pressures and competition.

The role of extinction

Extinction is a natural consequence of natural selection. As environments change, species that fail to adapt die out, while new species better suited to the conditions take their place. Darwin points out that the fossil record supports this view, showing a progression of life forms over geological time. While some critics argue that the gaps in the fossil record weaken his theory, Darwin counters that fossilization is a rare event, and many intermediate forms may never be found.

Objections and responses

Darwin anticipates several objections to his theory. One major challenge is the complexity of certain biological structures, such as the eye, which seem too intricate to have evolved through gradual changes. In response, he argues that even a partially developed eye could still provide a survival advantage, and over time, small improvements could lead to the complex structures seen in modern species.

Another objection concerns the apparent stability of species. Some critics argue that if natural selection were constantly at work, we should see more obvious transitions between species. Darwin suggests that evolution operates over such vast timescales that human observation is limited in its ability to detect gradual changes.

Implications of natural selection

Darwin’s theory has profound implications for our understanding of life. It challenges the traditional view that species were individually created and instead proposes a dynamic, ever-changing natural world. By suggesting that all species, including humans, have evolved from common ancestors, Darwin redefines humanity’s place in nature.

His ideas also influence a wide range of scientific disciplines beyond biology. In psychology, they inspire studies on human behavior and instincts. In sociology, they influence theories about social competition and adaptation. Even in medicine, Darwin’s insights help explain bacterial resistance to antibiotics and the evolution of diseases.

---

In On Natural Selection, Darwin presents a compelling argument for the theory that would revolutionize biology. His meticulous observations, logical reasoning, and careful responses to potential criticisms make his case highly persuasive. While the concept of evolution was controversial in his time, it has since been overwhelmingly supported by evidence from genetics, paleontology, and comparative anatomy.

Darwin’s work remains one of the most significant contributions to scientific thought, forever altering our understanding of the natural world and our place within it.