DREIESKIVA​|Roald Kvam

Castiglione’s How to Achieve True Greatness is a seminal Renaissance text that explores the qualities, virtues, and skills necessary for an individual to rise to prominence, particularly within the courtly society of the time. Castiglione, a diplomat and courtier himself, presents his ideas through a fictionalized dialogue set in the court of Urbino, where noblemen and scholars engage in discussions about the ideal courtier and the path to greatness.

Let’s explore…

Historical and intellectual context

Written during the early 16th century, How to Achieve True Greatness is an excerpt from Castiglione’s larger work, The Book of the Courtier (Il Cortegiano). This was a period of great political instability in Italy, with warring city-states and shifting allegiances among powerful families and foreign rulers. It was also a time of intellectual flourishing, as humanist thought emphasized individual excellence, self-cultivation, and moral virtue. Castiglione’s text reflects these ideals, merging classical philosophy with contemporary notions of refined behavior and leadership.

The ideal courtier and the path to greatness

At the heart of Castiglione’s treatise is the concept of the ideal courtier—a person of noble birth who embodies grace, intelligence, and virtue. According to Castiglione, true greatness is not merely about achieving power or fame but about cultivating a balanced and honorable character. He outlines several key qualities necessary for achieving such greatness:

1. Grace and effortless mastery (Sprezzatura)

One of Castiglione’s most famous concepts is sprezzatura, or the art of making difficult actions appear effortless. This quality, he argues, is essential for a courtier to maintain an air of confidence and control. True greatness comes not from displaying effort but from concealing it, making excellence seem natural and innate rather than forced or calculated.

2. The fusion of arms and letters

Castiglione insists that a great person should be well-versed in both the arts of war and intellectual pursuits. A balance between martial prowess and scholarly refinement ensures that a courtier can navigate both the battlefield and the royal court with equal competence. He draws on classical ideals, particularly those of Cicero and Aristotle, who advocated for a well-rounded education as the foundation of personal excellence.

3. Moral integrity and virtue

While skill and education are vital, Castiglione underscores that true greatness cannot exist without moral integrity. He rejects deceit and manipulation, asserting that honor and honesty must guide a courtier’s actions. Unlike Niccolò Machiavelli, who in The Prince argues that rulers may need to use cunning and deception, Castiglione maintains that virtue and ethical conduct are fundamental to maintaining respect and lasting influence.

4. The power of eloquence and wit

A great individual must be articulate and persuasive. The ability to speak well and engage in refined conversation is central to success in courtly life. Castiglione emphasizes the importance of wit, humor, and rhetorical skill, suggesting that a person’s words can shape their reputation as much as their actions. His perspective aligns with the Renaissance ideal of the orator as someone who not only possesses knowledge but also knows how to communicate it effectively.

5. Cultivating beauty and aesthetic sensibility

Physical appearance and graceful movement are also part of Castiglione’s vision of greatness. While he acknowledges that beauty is ultimately secondary to virtue and intellect, he asserts that a pleasing appearance, good posture, and refined manners contribute to an individual’s overall presence and effectiveness in courtly society.

The role of women in achieving greatness

Unlike many other Renaissance texts, How to Achieve True Greatness includes discussions on the role of women in courtly life. Castiglione portrays women as essential participants in intellectual and social circles, capable of wit, wisdom, and influence. However, while he respects their abilities, his vision remains rooted in traditional gender roles, suggesting that women’s greatness is often expressed through grace, charm, and moral virtue rather than direct political or military power.

The relationship between the courtier and the prince

Castiglione also delves into the relationship between the courtier and the ruler. He envisions the courtier as both an advisor and an influencer, one who can guide the prince toward just and wise governance. This perspective aligns with the Renaissance humanist belief that education and moral integrity can shape political leaders for the better. The courtier must, therefore, be skilled not only in diplomacy but also in subtly persuading the ruler to act with fairness and prudence.

The ultimate purpose of greatness

For Castiglione, the pursuit of greatness is not about personal gain but about serving the greater good. True greatness is achieved through a combination of self-improvement, ethical leadership, and contributions to society. His vision reflects the Renaissance ideal of the homo universalis (universal man), an individual who excels in multiple fields and uses their abilities for the benefit of others.

Influence and legacy

Castiglione’s work had a profound impact on European thought and courtly culture. His ideas influenced generations of aristocrats, diplomats, and scholars, shaping ideals of gentlemanly behavior well into the modern era. The concept of sprezzatura remains a hallmark of refined social conduct, while his emphasis on the fusion of intellect and action continues to resonate in discussions about leadership and personal development.

---

Castiglione’s How to Achieve True Greatness offers a timeless exploration of personal excellence, leadership, and ethical conduct. His vision of greatness transcends mere ambition, advocating instead for a life guided by virtue, grace, and service to others. In an era marked by political upheaval and social transformation, Castiglione’s insights remain relevant, reminding us that true greatness is not just about power but about the character and wisdom with which one wields it.